Injury Law Specialists

England & Wales

Medical Negligence Claims: When Could You Claim Compensation?

Medical negligence claims explained: how compensation is assessed for substandard medical care in England and Wales

Medical negligence claims are legal claims for compensation where care that falls below the standard reasonably expected causes a patient injury, makes a condition worse or leads to another measurable loss. If something has gone badly wrong during your treatment, you are probably asking a simple question. Was that negligence, and could I claim for it?

This guide sets out how that question is answered in England and Wales, what actually has to be proved, how long you have, and what the process looks like from the inside. It is written to help you understand the position before you speak to anyone.

Last reviewed 22 October 2026Jurisdiction: England & Wales

Key takeaways

  • Medical negligence claims may be possible where care falls below the standard reasonably expected and that failure causes avoidable harm.
  • A poor outcome alone is not negligence. Treatment can fail without anyone being at fault.
  • Two things usually have to be proved: that the care was negligent, and that the negligence caused additional harm.
  • In England and Wales court proceedings normally have to start within three years of the treatment or your later date of knowledge.
  • Complaining to the NHS does not pause that three year period, so advice should be taken promptly.

Most people who contact a solicitor about medical negligence do so reluctantly. They are not looking for a fight with a doctor or a hospital. They want to understand what happened, and whether what happened was avoidable.

That instinct is worth respecting. The law takes the same view. It does not treat every unsatisfactory result as somebody's fault, because medicine carries risk and even careful treatment sometimes fails. What the law does address is care that falls below what a competent professional would have provided, where that shortfall causes harm that would otherwise not have occurred.

If you are trying to work out whether you have a claim, the practical place to start is not with the outcome, but with the standard of care and the cause of the harm. The rest of this guide deals with those two things, then with time limits, evidence and what happens next.

What is a medical negligence claim?

A medical negligence claim is a claim for compensation where substandard medical treatment causes a patient injury, worsens an existing condition or produces a measurable loss.

Medical negligence is more often called clinical negligence by lawyers, and the two terms mean the same thing. The claim is not about punishing anyone. It is about identifying what went wrong, establishing whether that fell below an acceptable standard, and putting you back, so far as money can, in the position you would have been in without the harm.

Claims can arise in almost any part of healthcare. In practice they most often involve NHS trusts and hospitals, GPs, private clinics, surgeons and consultants, nursing care, dentists, pharmacists, maternity services, diagnostic services and physiotherapy.

Our medical negligence solicitors can look at what happened and explain whether there may be grounds to investigate further. That conversation does not commit you to anything.

When could you claim compensation for medical negligence?

You could claim where the care you received fell below an acceptable professional standard and, on the balance of probabilities, that failure caused or materially contributed to an injury or loss. Both parts are required, and the second is the one that usually decides the case.

1. Was there a breach of duty?

Every clinician owes a duty to take reasonable care. A breach arises where the diagnosis, treatment or advice falls below the standard reasonably expected in the circumstances.

2. Did it cause harm?

It is not enough that a mistake was made. You must show the mistake caused or materially contributed to harm you would not otherwise have suffered.

The test for the first of those is well established. In Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] the court held that a clinician is not negligent if they acted in accordance with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of professionals in that field. That principle was refined in Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority [1997], where the House of Lords added that such an opinion must also be capable of withstanding logical analysis. A body of opinion cannot be used to defend a decision that no reasonable clinician could have made.

The second question, causation, is where cases are most often lost. Take a delayed diagnosis. The legal question is not simply whether the diagnosis was late. It is whether the outcome would probably have been better if it had been made sooner. If the answer is that treatment would have made no real difference, there may be no claim, however unsatisfactory the delay.

That distinction is the reason independent medical evidence sits at the centre of these claims. More on that below.

What types of medical negligence can lead to a claim?

Claims commonly arise from delayed diagnosis, misdiagnosis, surgical errors, medication mistakes, maternity failures and consent failures. What matters is not the label on the mistake, but whether the standard of care was met and whether the failure caused harm.

  • Delayed diagnosis

    Cancer, infection or a fracture identified too late, where earlier treatment would probably have helped.

  • Misdiagnosis

    The wrong condition treated, so the right treatment is either delayed or never given.

  • Surgical errors

    Injury to a structure that should not have been touched, or aftercare that fell short.

  • Medication errors

    Wrong drug, wrong dose, or a known interaction or allergy that should have been checked.

  • GP failures

    Symptoms not investigated, or a referral that should have been made and was not.

  • Maternity and birth injuries

    Failures in monitoring, delivery or postnatal care, with consequences for mother or baby.

  • Dental negligence

    Treatment carried out outside accepted practice, or avoidable damage during it.

  • Consent failures

    Material risks or reasonable alternatives not properly discussed before treatment.

  • Never events

    Serious, wholly preventable incidents such as a retained surgical instrument.

If your circumstances involved an injury with long term consequences, our guide to serious injury claims explains how claims involving rehabilitation, care and future loss are approached.

Can you claim simply because treatment went wrong?

No. An unexpected complication, an operation that did not work, or a condition that got worse does not by itself amount to negligence. Medicine carries inherent risk, and some patients have poor outcomes despite entirely appropriate care.

Poor outcome only

A recognised complication occurs despite appropriate treatment, reasonable monitoring and proper consent. Nothing was done wrong. This is not usually a claim.

Potential negligence

A clinician fails to take a step that a competent professional should have taken, and harm follows that would probably have been avoided. This may be a claim.

This is the single most common misunderstanding we see. People often assume that because the result was bad, someone must be to blame. It is also the reason some genuinely strong claims are never investigated, because the person assumed nothing could be done.

Can a failure to warn about risks amount to negligence?

Yes, potentially. A clinician should take reasonable care to make sure you are aware of the material risks of a proposed treatment and of the reasonable alternatives, so that you can make a genuinely informed decision.

The leading case is Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11, in which the Supreme Court moved away from a purely medical model of consent. The judgment emphasised a real dialogue between clinician and patient about material risks and reasonable alternatives, rather than treating consent as a formality signed before treatment.

A claim on this basis still has to show harm. It is not enough that a risk was not mentioned. The question is whether a reasonable person in your position would have attached significance to that risk, and whether you would have chosen differently had you been told.

The full judgment is available from the UK Supreme Court.

How long do you have to make a medical negligence claim?

In England and Wales, court proceedings for a personal injury claim, including medical negligence, normally have to be started within three years. That period runs from the date of the negligent treatment, or from your date of knowledge if that is later.

The rule comes from section 11 of the Limitation Act 1980. The distinction between the date of treatment and the date of knowledge matters, because harm from medical care often becomes apparent only much later, after further investigation or a second opinion.

Knowledge is not the same as suspicion. The question is when you first knew, or ought reasonably to have known, that the injury was significant and attributable in a broad sense to the treatment. It is a question of fact, and it is assessed on the circumstances of the individual case.

It is worth being blunt here. People lose the right to claim because they were waiting for an investigation, waiting for a complaint to be answered, or waiting until they felt ready. None of those pauses time. If you are unsure of your position, ask early.

Are there exceptions to the three year limit?

Yes, and they can be decisive. The main exceptions are:

Children

Where the injured person was a child, the three year period does not begin until their eighteenth birthday. Proceedings can generally be brought up to their twenty first birthday, or earlier on their behalf by a litigation friend.

People lacking mental capacity

Where a person lacks the relevant mental capacity, the limitation period is suspended. Capacity here is a legal question as well as a medical one, and needs to be considered carefully rather than assumed.

Where the patient has died

Different provisions apply to claims arising from a death. The period may run from the date of death or from the personal representative's date of knowledge, if that is later. Fatal claims raise questions about eligibility as well as time, so they are best discussed directly.

The court's discretion to extend time

Section 33 of the Limitation Act 1980 allows a court, in certain personal injury and death claims, to disapply the time limit where it is equitable to do so. This is a discretion, not an entitlement, and it should never be relied upon as a reason to delay. Applications of this kind are difficult and contingent.

Our guide to personal injury claim time limits covers the date of knowledge rules and these exceptions in more depth.

What evidence is needed for a medical negligence claim?

A claim normally needs medical records, independent expert opinion, a factual account of what happened and evidence of financial loss. The expert evidence ordinarily has to address the standard of care and causation separately.

Records and documents

  • GP records and hospital records
  • Prescriptions and medication charts
  • Scans, test results and clinical reports
  • Clinic letters and discharge summaries
  • Any correspondence with the provider

Independent medical opinion

Experts are instructed to answer specific questions. Common practice is to use one expert on the standard of care, another on causation, and often a third on your current condition and prognosis. This is recognised in the pre-action protocol.

Do not be put off because you do not hold all of the records yourself. Hospital and GP records can usually be obtained as part of investigating a claim, and they are the starting point rather than something you have to assemble.

What does help is your own account, written while it is still fresh. A plain chronology, kept in your own words, noting dates, who said what and what you were told, is genuinely useful. If you have kept letters, appointment cards or a symptom diary, keep them.

Evidence of financial loss matters too, because it is recoverable. Payslips, benefit statements, invoices for treatment and travel receipts are all worth retaining. Our page on recovering medical and rehabilitation costs explains how treatment costs are treated.

What happens during a medical negligence claim?

A claim usually begins with investigation rather than litigation. Records are obtained, instructions taken and expert evidence considered before anything is sent to the defendant.

  1. 1

    Initial assessment

    Your account is taken, and the solicitor consults any records you already have. A view is formed on whether further investigation is justified.

  2. 2

    Medical records

    Requests are made for GP and hospital records, and they are reviewed for what happened and when.

  3. 3

    Expert evidence

    Independent experts are instructed on the standard of care, causation and your condition.

  4. 4

    Letter of Claim

    If the evidence supports it, a formal Letter of Claim is sent under the Clinical Disputes Pre-Action Protocol.

  5. 5

    Defendant investigation

    The defendant acknowledges the letter and investigates. The protocol allows a period for a reasoned response, and it can be extended with agreement.

  6. 6

    Negotiation or proceedings

    The claim may settle through negotiation, or court proceedings may be issued where liability, causation or quantum remains in dispute.

The formal procedure is set out in the Pre-Action Protocol for the Resolution of Clinical Disputes.

What compensation can you receive for medical negligence?

Compensation aims to put you, so far as money reasonably can, in the position you would have been in without the negligence. It is usually split into general damages for the injury itself and special damages for the financial losses.

General damages

  • Pain and suffering
  • Loss of amenity
  • Severity and duration of the injury
  • Effect on daily life
  • Prognosis and future symptoms

Special damages

  • Past and future loss of earnings
  • Care, including care by family
  • Treatment and rehabilitation
  • Travel and equipment
  • Home adaptations and future needs

General damages are assessed by reference to the Judicial College Guidelines, which set out ranges for different types of injury. Those ranges are a starting point, not a quotation for your case.

It is worth saying plainly that no one can tell you what your claim is worth at the outset. Any figure given before the medical evidence exists is a guess dressed up as advice. Our guide to how personal injury compensation is calculated explains the assessment in more detail.

Can you claim against the NHS, and what should you do first?

Yes. Where the treatment was provided by an NHS trust, the claim is usually brought against the trust rather than the individual clinician. Private providers can also be pursued, and the correct defendant depends on how the treatment was arranged.

If you think your care caused harm, the practical steps that help most, in order, are these.

  1. 1Get the treatment you still need. Nothing matters more than your health.
  2. 2Write down what happened while it is fresh, in your own words, with dates.
  3. 3Keep every letter, appointment card, prescription and receipt.
  4. 4Consider making a formal complaint if you want an explanation of what went wrong.
  5. 5Do not assume the complaint protects your time limit, because it does not.
  6. 6Ask a specialist medical negligence solicitor about your position, early.

You do not need to prove the claim before speaking to anyone. Establishing what happened and why is the solicitor's job, and much of it depends on records you do not yet have.

Our page on No Win No Fee funding explains how these claims are usually funded and what a success fee means in practice.

Frequently asked questions

Can I claim if a doctor made a mistake?

Possibly, but a mistake on its own is not enough. You would normally need to show the care fell below the standard reasonably expected and that this caused or materially contributed to an injury or loss. Both parts matter, and the second is often the harder one to prove.

Can I claim for a delayed diagnosis?

Yes, where the delay was negligent and it probably made the outcome worse. The central question is usually whether earlier diagnosis and treatment would have produced a materially better result. That is a question for independent medical evidence rather than for a lawyer alone.

How long do I have to make a medical negligence claim?

In England and Wales the usual period is three years from the date the treatment happened or from your date of knowledge, if that is later. Some cases are treated differently. Because the deadline is strict, it is worth asking about time limits early even if you are unsure about the merits.

Does complaining to the NHS protect my time limit?

No. A complaint and a compensation claim are separate processes, and starting or continuing a complaint does not stop time running against a claim. It is quite common for people to assume the clock pauses while the hospital investigates. It does not.

Can I make a claim against the NHS rather than the doctor?

Often, yes. Where the treatment was provided by an NHS trust, the claim is usually brought against the trust rather than the individual clinician. The trust is the body that employs and indemnifies the staff involved.

How much compensation could I receive?

There is no standard figure and nobody can give you a reliable number before the medical evidence is in. What compensation is worth depends on the injury, the prognosis, the effect on your life, and the financial losses arising from it.

Can I claim for distress or anxiety caused by medical negligence?

Sometimes. A recognised psychiatric injury can form part of a claim where it is properly evidenced. General distress or upset, without more, does not usually attract compensation on its own. This is a matter to discuss openly with a solicitor.

Not sure whether your care was negligent?

You do not need to be certain before you ask. A short conversation is usually enough to tell you whether your circumstances are worth looking at more closely, and what the next step would be if they are.

This guide is general information about medical negligence claims in England and Wales. It is not legal advice about your case. Whether a claim can be made, and by when, depends on the facts and evidence. Injury Law Specialists is a marketing and advertising platform and is not a law firm. Legal services are provided by MB Solicitors, a trading name of MB Legal Solicitors Ltd, regulated by the SRA under SRA ID 8000764.